User Feedback 2018
The users decide whether a product is successful and both professionals and ambitioned private users expect ergonomics and grip from a modern screwdriver handle.
In February 2018 we commissioned Krämer Marktforschung GmbH to conduct an objective and neutral customer survey about screwdriver handles. In hardware stores all over Germany 315 participants, professionals as well as DiYers, could test and rate 5 different handles from the top segment of German manufacturers.
Der Test:
Test 1:
5 screwdrivers were placed in a opaque box where the participants could not see them (and identify the brands) but only access the tools with their hands. The evaluation criteria at this step were ergonomics and haptic perception of the handles. The testers were asked to sort the handles inside the box from most agreeable to least agreeable.
The result of test 1 was not disclosed before test 2.
Test 2:
Here all 5 specimens were used for turning screws at medium and high torque at different angles.
Result:
In both tests (blind and usage) Ergonic was voted twice as often as the runner-up to be the best screwdriver in the field. The results are almost identical for the blind test and the usage test. No significant difference could be measured between the answers of professionals and DiY-users.
Felo Ergonic is in the lead by a large margin.
Total
Percentage
Hardware store 1
25
8%
Hardware store 2
149
47%
Hardware store 3
11
3%
Hardware store 4
96
30%
Hardware store 5
34
11%
Total
315
100%
Total
Percentage
Male
304
97%
Female
11
3%
No answer
0
0%
Total
315
100%
Total
Percentage
18-29 years
32
10%
30-39 years
64
20%
40-49 years
64
20%
50-59 years
74
230%
60 and over
81
26%
No answer
0
0%
Total
315
100%
Total
Percentage
Mainly at work
227
72%
Mainly privately
88
28%
No answer
0
0%
Total
315
100%
Total
Percentage
Craftsmen/trade
203
64%
Industry
24
8%
No answer
0
0%
Total
227
72%
The box in front of you contains 5 screwdrivers. Please take each of them into your hands to find out which one is most agreeable to the touch (your haptic perception). Please place the screwdriver with the best haptics far left and the rest of the specimens in descending order right of the top-runner (2nd choice, 3rd choice etc).
Total
Percentage
Relatively
Felo (1. Choice)
171
54%
Felo (2. Choice)
84
27%
Felo (3. Choice)
40
13%
Felo (4. Choice)
11
3%
Felo (5. Choice)
9
3%
4,26
Competitor A (1. Choice)
75
24%
Competitor A (2. Choice)
83
26%
Competitor A (3. Choice)
56
18%
Competitor A (4. Choice)
46
15%
Competitor A (5. Choice)
55
17%
3,24
Competitor B (1. Choice)
26
8%
Competitor B (2. Choice)
62
20%
Competitor B (3. Choice)
69
22%
Competitor B (4. Choice)
90
29%
Competitor B (5. Choice)
68
22%
2,64
Competitor C (1. Choice)
25
8%
Competitor C (2. Choice)
53
17%
Competitor C (3. Choice)
70
22%
Competitor C (4. Choice)
81
26%
Competitor C (5. Choice)
86
27%
2,52
Competitor D (1. Choice)
18
6%
Competitor D (2. Choice)
33
10%
Competitor D (3. Choice)
80
25%
Competitor D (4. Choice)
87
28%
Competitor D (5. Choice)
97
31%
2,33
In our usage test we would like to ask you to apply the screwdrivers at different torque and work angles. Please rate every screwdriver according to its ergonomics. After the application please place the top runner on the utmost left side and the others in descending order to the right of this item.
Total
Percentage
Relatively
Felo (1. Choice)
168
54%
Felo (2. Choice)
89
27%
Felo (3. Choice)
37
13%
Felo (4. Choice)
11
3%
Felo (5. Choice)
10
3%
4,25
Competitor A (1. Choice)
83
26%
Competitor A (2. Choice)
76
24%
Competitor A (3. Choice)
64
20%
Competitor A (4. Choice)
40
13%
Competitor A (5. Choice)
52
17%
3,31
Competitor B (1. Choice)
26
8%
Competitor B (2. Choice)
71
23%
Competitor B (3. Choice)
65
21%
Competitor B (4. Choice)
99
31%
Competitor B (5. Choice)
54
17%
2,73
Competitor C (1. Choice)
21
7%
Competitor C (2. Choice)
46
15%
Competitor C (3. Choice)
75
24%
Competitor C (4. Choice)
80
25%
Competitor C (5. Choice)
93
30%
2,43
Competitor D (1. Choice)
17
5%
Competitor D (2. Choice)
33
10%
Competitor D (3. Choice)
74
23%
Competitor D (4. Choice)
85
27%
Competitor D (5. Choice)
106
34%
2,27